Act I - Scene III
[Venice] |
Enter Bassanio with Shylock the Jew. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Enter Antonio. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Exit. |
|
|
|
Exeunt. |
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
A major theme of this play is the racial enmity between Jews and Christians. The hatred between Antonio and Shylock can be read as a portrait that reflects larger patterns of racial hatred. Notice that Shakespeare's play offers a more complex understanding of how racial tensions play out in these characters's interactions beyond racial hatred. Shylock does not simply hate Antonio because he is a Christian, but because Antonio's Christian ethics threaten Shylock's livelihood.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
Here "bated breath" means holding one's tongue or meekly waiting for something to happen. Shylock uses this term to point out the Christian's hypocrisy in expecting him to loan them 3,000 ducats while believing that he should be subservient to them.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
Though the Christians have characterized Shylock as a greedy man because he earns money off of interest, Shylock's use of this bond shows that profit is not the most important thing to him. It suggests that the Christians have mischaracterized Shylock, and that he is actually one of the only characters with principals in the play.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
Here Shylock prays to Abraham to excuse himself for making a bond to take another man's flesh. He justifies his bond in saying that a pound of man's flesh has no monetary value and that he will not profit from it. This suggests that Shylock has higher aims than money in making this bond: perhaps punishing Antonio for his abuse of the Jews, or perhaps demonstrating the Christians's love of money above all else.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
Antonio believes that his ships will return safely and he will have no problem paying off his bond. However, this certainty is in direct conflict with everything the audience has heard so far about Antonio's ships and investments. Antonio is over confident about the security of his investments; this foreshadows that this cockiness will end badly for him.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
Shylock equalizes the body with money here when he asks Antonio to promise to give a pound of his flesh for each pound he does not pay back. While this has been read as a sign of Shylock's savagery, some critics see this as Shylock pointing out the hypocrisy of the Christians: any Christian who believed his body was a sacred gift from God would not make this bond. However, because money is more important to Antonio than God, he does agree to take this bond.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
Shylock claims that he chooses to take this bond as a sign of peace between himself and Antonio. It is unclear whether or not these lines are meant to be sincere or sarcastic, or whether or not they are intended to make Shylock seem endearing or seem like a villain.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
In this metaphor, Antonio argues that money making money is unnatural. Coins are barren, or infertile, and thus should not be able to breed more coins. In other words, more money should not be made from interest.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
Notice that Antonio confirms his abusive behavior. While the audience could believe that Shylock is over exaggerating or slandering Antonio, Antonio's affirmation here shows that Shylock was not lying.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
This is a colloquial term that means to spit phlegm onto. Shylock here points to the irony that Antonio now comes to him for the very thing for which he so violently hated Shylock. This speech makes Antonio's character hypocritical and unlikable.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
Shylock catalogues particularly despicable behavior on Antonio's part. He not only calls him names, he spits on him in the street. It is unclear whether or not Shakespeare intended this to be funny or heart wrenching to his audience; whether this speech was supposed to endear them to Shylock or to Antonio. However, it is worth noting that other plays of this time, including Shakespeare's source text, did not give Jewish characters the chance to speak against their treatment in this manner.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
Here Shylock directly addresses what the audience may have inferred from Antonio and Shylock's exchange: Antonio does not only lend money without interest, he publicly shames and bullies Shylock because he does.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
Again Antonio interrupts Shylock before he is able to tell Antonio what to mark. There are no stage directions here to suggest that the following speech is an aside to Bassanio that reveals genuine fear of Shylock. Instead, Antonio seems to say this in front of Shylock as if he weren't there, demonstrating an arrogant disregard for the man who is supposed to lend them money.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
Notice how Antonio dismisses Shylock's story and publicly mocks him. This type of dismissal demonstrates Antonio's lack of respect for Shylock and suggests that he holds money lenders in contempt.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
While Antonio seems to see interest as taking advantage of someone else, Shylock tells a story in which someone leverages their skills in order to succeed; Jacob achieves his money through ingenuity. This could also be a dig at Antonio and Bassanio who are not attempting to acquire money through their intellect or skills but through an extravagant loan. It could also suggest that Shylock and Jacob are similar in that both must rely on their intelligence to survive in an unfriendly system.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
This interruption demonstrates Antonio's lack of respect for Shylock and his business practices. Antonio is obviously contemptuous of the interest Shylock collects on his loans.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
Jacob was Isaac's son. With the help of his mother Rebecca, he was abel to trick his father into giving him his brother's inheritance and becoming Isaac's third heir.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
In Genesis 30 of the Old Testament, Jacob makes a deal with Laban, the father of Rachel, the woman he wants to marry. Laban tells him that he can keep any of the multicolored sheep in the herd, so Jacob places a spotted plant in front of the breeding sheep. This causes many of the sheep to become spotted like the plant and increases Jacob's wealth. Jacob essentially rigs the deal so that he gains more than Laban.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
Notice how Antonio and Shylock differ here. Shylock is defined by his beliefs while Antonio quickly breaks his principals for his friend's vain desire.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
By this Shylock means that he and other Jewish lenders were just talking about Antonio, presumably because Antonio's interest free loans have spoiled their business. Notice again that Shylock is associated with consumption and eating.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
Catholics were explicitly prohibited from lending money and collecting interest by Catholic Church law in this time. Because Jews were essentially universally hated across medieval and Early Modern Europe, moneylending became one of few positions open to them. Even though the practice of loaning money was essential to Venice's merchant economy, collecting debts led to more Christian resentment towards the Jewish community.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
Metaphors of consumption and devouring reoccur throughout this play, especially in relation to Shylock. One explanation could be the wide-held Early Modern belief in "blood-libel," the anti-semitic belief that Jews used Christian blood to prepare their Passover bread. Another explanation is that Shylock "feeds" or "consumes" in a different way than the Christians. While the Christians consume material items and obsess over money, Shylock "feeds" his beliefs, feelings, and internal motivations.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
While many other plays at this time, including Shakespeare's source text The Jew of Malta by Christopher Marlowe, gave audiences a one dimensional Jewish villain, Shakespeare gives Shylock more of a motive to hate Antonio. Antonio offers loans without interest and debases the entire money lending market through which Shylock makes his living.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
Rialto is a Venetian island that served as the mercantile quarter in medieval Venice. In 1591, the Rialto Bridge was completed and connected Rialto to the San Marco Islands.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
Unlike Antonio's friends who seem to have few beliefs, except for the belief in the power and importance of money, Shylock believes in his religion over money. He will not sacrifice his religion in order to make this business deal. In this sense, a sharp distinction is made between the Christians and Shylock: Shylock is the more principled of the two.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
The "Nazarite" is a reference to Jesus Christ. Christians at this time speculated that Jews did not eat pork because they believed Jesus had banished a demon into a herd of swine, tainting the meat. However, Jews do not eat pork because it is not kosher. That Shylock makes this claim, reminds us that he is a Jewish character written by a Christian author who does not understand Jewish customs.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
The Merchant of Venice is controversial because of its anti-semitic treatment of Shylock, the Jewish character in the play. After King Edward's Edict of Expulsion in 1290, anyone practicing the Jewish faith in England had to do so secretly or face persecution. When Shakespeare wrote this play in 1605, his audience would have only known about Jewish people from stories and stereotypes associated with them. Thus, Shylock can be read (and probably was intended) as a comedic caricature of Jewish stereotypes. Many modern scholars have chosen to read Shylock sympathetically, as a victim of his circumstances rather than a straightforward villain.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
Shylock's desire to take the bond despite the large chance that Antonio will not have the money to cover the bond suggests that he has ulterior motives for loaning Antonio the money. The audience once again gets the sense that Shylock does not like Antonio or that Shylock is seeking revenge for some unknown injury. Notice that Shakespeare does not offer the audience motivation for Shylock's actions.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
Shylock highlights the uncertainty of Antonio's wealth. Sailing at the time was extremely hazardous because of natural disasters, poorly made vessels, and human frailty. This list of potential disasters foreshadows the main conflict in the play and shows Antonio's imprudence in taking this bond before he knows how his ships will fair.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
Though Bassanio claims that Antonio is a good man with his rhetorical question, Shylock corrects him to say that Antonio is not "good" in a moral sense but rather that he is "good" for the money. This suggests that Shylock and Antonio do not like each other.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
In this context, Bassanio means "will you give me the answer I want?" Bassanio is eagerly waiting for Shylock to agree to grant Antonio the loan.
-
— Caitlin, Owl Eyes Staff
A ducat was currency of the Venetian Republic from 1284 through the Renaissance. They were small, valuable gold coins. Three thousand ducats was an extremely large amount of money; it roughly equals about 500,000 dollars by today's standards.